How did the Pakistani delegation's meeting with Mullah Hibatullah's representatives unfold?
By Fazl Ahmad Manawi, Former Minister of Justice of Afghanistan, especially for Sangar
Reliable sources report that on October 22, a Pakistani delegation led by General Inayat Hussain visited Kandahar. The delegation consisted of four representatives of the security services and one representative of Pakistan's Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Pakistani consular officials based in Kabul and Kandahar also participated in the visit.
According to the sources, the delegation entered Afghanistan through Spin Boldak at 9 a.m. that day, held talks with Taliban officials in Kandahar, and returned to Quetta at 10 p.m.
Those present at the meeting included Mullah Shirin, Governor of Kandahar; Mullah Talib; Zabihullah Mujahid, the Taliban's official spokesman; Sadr Ibrahim, Deputy Minister of Interior in the Taliban administration; Mufti Lutfullah Hakimi, Chief Inspector of the Taliban's Ministry of Defense; and Mullah Abdul Quddus, head of Taliban military intelligence. These officials reportedly traveled from Kabul to Kandahar.
The Pakistani delegation raised five key issues with the Taliban.
1 - Handover of Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) leaders. Pakistan demanded the handover of TTP leaders residing in Afghanistan. Islamabad reportedly provided the Taliban with the addresses and precise coordinates of each individual's whereabouts.
2 - Preventing Afghan militants from entering Pakistan. The Pakistani delegation demanded measures to prevent Afghan militants from crossing into Pakistani territory and participating in armed clashes against the country's government.
3 - Sale of Taliban properties in Pakistan. Pakistan demanded that Taliban members sell their houses, properties, and other assets to the Pakistani government and that the owners permanently leave the country.
4 - Closure of the Indian consulate in Jalalabad. The Pakistani delegation demanded the closure of India's consulate in Jalalabad.
5 - Preventing the transit of Russian logistical assistance to Iran. Pakistan demanded an end to the transportation of Russian logistical assistance through Afghan territory to Iran. According to the sources, this demand was primarily raised in the interests of Pakistan's allies.
The Taliban's Response to Pakistan's Demands
According to the sources, the Taliban responded positively to the demand for the handover of Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan leaders. In return, however, they demanded the closure of all offices and training centers operated by their opponents on Pakistani territory.
In this regard, the Taliban presented the Pakistani side with documents which, they claimed, demonstrated the existence of offices and training facilities belonging to Taliban opponents in Pakistan, as well as the infiltration of armed groups from Pakistan into Afghanistan with Pakistani training and logistical support. Armed clashes in Nuristan were also mentioned in this context.
The Taliban also gave a positive response to the demand to prevent Afghan militants from entering Pakistan. However, they insisted that the equipment, logistical resources, and financial assistance provided to Pakistan by the United States and Western countries for this purpose be transferred directly to the Taliban.
The Taliban argued that without the necessary equipment and financial resources, they lacked sufficient capacity to control Afghanistan's eastern and southern borders.
Regarding the sale of Taliban properties and other assets in Pakistan, the movement also agreed, on the condition that the Pakistani government purchase these properties at current market prices.
As for the Indian consulate in Jalalabad, the Taliban stated that they would agree to its closure, provided that Pakistan's consulate in the same city was closed simultaneously.
On the issue of Russian logistical assistance allegedly being transported to Iran through Afghanistan, the Taliban denied that such shipments were taking place and emphasized that they did not intend to side with Iran in any confrontation between the United States and Arab countries, on the one hand, and Iran, on the other.
A One-Month Deadline and the Prospects for Pakistan–Taliban Relations
According to the information provided, the two sides established a one-month deadline for fulfilling the commitments discussed during the meeting. However, given the deep disagreements and mutual distrust between them, implementing these understandings will face serious challenges. There is a possibility of further escalation in tensions between Pakistan and the Taliban in the coming months.
Over the past two years, Pakistan has not pursued a consistent policy toward the Taliban, repeatedly shifting between increased pressure and attempts to ease tensions. This approach can be viewed as part of Islamabad's efforts to secure support from regional countries, Afghanistan's neighbors, the United States, and Western governments in its confrontation with the Taliban.
Meanwhile, Russia's and Iran's engagement with the Taliban, along with the tactical support they have provided to the movement, has further complicated Pakistan's regional calculations. This situation, combined with the existing security disagreements between the two sides, makes the prospect of reaching a lasting understanding increasingly difficult.
It appears that the one-month deadline, rather than resolving fundamental disagreements, could pave the way for a new round of pressure and confrontation between Pakistan and the Taliban. If the two sides fail to fulfill the commitments under discussion, the risk of further deterioration in relations and a deepening crisis in the coming months will become increasingly serious.